Showing posts with label D&D 5E. Show all posts
Showing posts with label D&D 5E. Show all posts

Evaluating Systems

[Edit: I changed out one fantasy game for another, as I concluded that I preferred the more streamlined system of Vagabonds of Dyfed over the more complex, move-based system of Freebooters on the Frontier 2e. 4/27/21]

Recently taking a moment to reflect, I've found myself hip-deep in middle-age. It happens to a lot of us. I realized that, in a likelihood, I've probably got as many games ahead of me as I do behind me. (It's possible this is inaccurate, as I did take ~20 years off from RPGs, but in the interest of an introspective post, let's just roll with that estimate.) I looked back at past campaigns, thinking, They were numerous, but the variety of RPG systems across them was very limited. Like many RPG hobbyists, I tend to collect a lot of game systems -- but, if I'm being honest with myself, there's not a very high chance that I'll actually spend much time (if any) playing those systems.

Admittedly, it's fun to simply collect RPG rulebooks, even if you're not going to necessarily play them all. And, if you're like me, you also get enjoyment out of reading them and expanding your awareness of the variety of rules and mechanics across the hobby. But, that's not ultimately why we're here: we're here to play or run them at the table. So this pause for reflection got me reading. I decided to read through all the rulebooks that I owned (in some cases, it was a quicker read, closer to skimming) so that I might identify my personal "core" games -- those that I turn to as favorites and that I'd be most likely to enjoy running for others. I began a survey of my collection to help me wrap my brain around exactly what I had, how each worked on the simplest level, and how much I valued each personally.

Version Control

I wrote this post originally as an email to two friends of mine, mostly as an effort to formally sketch out my thoughts after a short-yet-intense bout of RPG introspection and analysis. I've tweaked the original email a little and added some extra thoughts that I've had since then. But I felt it was worth sharing here as it represents a central conclusion that I've reached in my handling of D&D-style RPGs. 

Recently, I felt the need to identify my favorite iteration of D&D.

Not to the exclusion of other versions -- honestly, I love them all and would probably play any version I could -- but just to know, for myself, which one I might go to first if I wanted to run a campaign. Time being limited as it is, it's important to know the most effective way of playing favorites. (Admittedly, this was also to help me prioritize what supplements to pick up if I were going to invest in future purchases).

I ended up sketching out a rough comparison matrix on a piece of paper, comparing the features that each had built-in or homebrewed by the community. I considered several factors, including things like AC mechanic, character class options, skill systems, even which dice were most heavily used. I then compared this against the parts that were either missing or inelegantly designed by my estimation, those parts that I would have to alter or homebrew up myself to make it a game that I'd consider ideal.